Breaking down the latest in Erik Karlsson trade talks with Penguins

Pittsburgh Penguins, Erik Karlsson (Photo by Zac BonDurant/Getty Images)
Pittsburgh Penguins, Erik Karlsson (Photo by Zac BonDurant/Getty Images) /

The start of the NHL Free Agency period has been an active one for the Penguins. The front office went on a signing spree yesterday, strengthening our team’s defense.

Most notably, they locked down Ryan Graves for a six-year deal, which could stabilize our defensive lineup. At 6’5″ and 220 pounds, expect Graves to command on the ice and log tough minutes this upcoming season.

Despite these important moves, talks have been swirling about an even bigger acquisition – Erik Karlsson. A two-time Norris Trophy winner, Karlsson’s offensive skills from the blue line are nearly unmatched in the NHL. Karlsson’s addition to our team would be an absolute game-changer, but the question remains among fans: where would he fit in, and how can the Penguins pull off this trade?

Let’s start by determining where Karlsson would fit into our lineup. The Swedish defenseman, known for his ability to contribute significantly to the offense, could create a dynamic pairing with Kris Letang, our long-standing defenseman.

This combination could present a potent offensive threat from the blue line, something the Penguins could leverage to support their attack at the net. Alongside the defensive depth provided by Ryan Graves, the potential addition of Karlsson would further solidify our defense while adding a new dimension to our game.

Penguins GM Kyle Dubas recently spoke about bringing in a player of Karlsson’s caliber. He said,

"“When there’s a player like that who comes available, I think that especially with the core group and how special that core group of people is in the room — both the coaching staff and the players, and the group that surrounds the team — I think it’s incumbent on me to reach out and see if there’s a fit there for us. That was the way I viewed that entire situation. I don’t want to get too much into it because I think some of it is private and doesn’t involve a player who is ours, so I don’t want to cross any league (tampering) lines and upset anybody. But at the same time … anytime there’s a player of that caliber who comes available throughout my time here, especially in this next stretch, it’s probably realistic to think that we’ll be involved or (will) see if there’s a way we can be involved to add them to our group”​"

This quote from Dubas suggests that the Penguins are open to bringing Karlsson into the team, provided it’s a good fit and they can make the cap space to acquire him.

Can the Pittsburgh Penguins make this trade happen?

The reality of acquiring Karlsson is a bit more complicated. His current contract with the Sharks carries an enormous cap hit of $11 million, not just for the next season but for the three following seasons.

Considering the cap constraints, this creates a major hurdle for any team, including the Penguins. Yet, many fans strongly believe that a deal could happen, and numerous reports indicate that the Penguins are among the groups in the mix, including the Carolina Hurricanes.

The Penguins must utilize considerable creativity and strategic planning to pull off a trade for Erik Karlsson. A trade would involve moving certain players to free up cap space. Jeff Petry, for instance, is one player whose contract could be moved to create the necessary room.

While it would be ideal if San Jose agreed to retain a portion of Karlsson’s salary, this seems unlikely, putting the puck in the Penguins’ rink to make the numbers work.

Moving beyond the usual suspects, the Penguins would have to consider a range of options, potentially looking at other players such as Marcus Pettersson, while valuable, might be moved to encourage this deal. This strategy would undoubtedly be complex and would require a careful balancing act to maintain the team’s competitive edge while adjusting its financial commitments.

Pens Labyrinth
Pens Labyrinth /

Want your voice heard? Join the Pens Labyrinth team!

Write for us!

The potential addition of Erik Karlsson is an exciting prospect for us Pens fans. His skill set would add a new dimension to our team and significantly boost our chances of competing for the Stanley Cup. While the financial hurdles are significant, the potential payoff could be huge.

As fans, all we can do is hope the front office can work magic and bring Karlsson to the Steel City.