It's been over two and a half years since the Pittsburgh Penguins traded away Jake Guentzel. That marked the first move to a rebuild for the Black and Gold, even though they have been competitive since. Moving on rom Guentzel to recoup young assets after refusing to sign the star winger was Kyle Dubas' first bold move as general manager. That trade now has a tree that continues to expand.
When you review the Jake Guentzel trade, it's clear that the Penguins were the clear losers of the deal. That is the normal outcome when you are moving out the best player of the trade. That being said, the Carolina Hurricanes didn't win a Stanely Cup and saw the forward move onto Tampa Bay in the offseason.
At the end of the day, this deal was not a great move by Pittsburgh, but they had few options to work with.
Dubas was able to land some mid-tier prospects out of Carolina's system, gain a journeyman NHL player, and two conditional picks, which reverted into a second-round choice in 2026. Unless some of the prospects that resulted from this trade tree turn things around for the Penguins, this Guentzel deal will haunt this franchise. It hasn't aged well as the star player continues to thrive elsewhere.
Pittsburgh Penguins trade tree surrounding Jake Guentzel will not stop anytime soon
Penguins received: Villie Koivunen, Harrison Brunicke, Tommy Novak, Markus Ruck, 2027 4th Round Pick
Penguins traded away/lost: Michael Bunting, Luke Schenn, Ty Smith, Jake Guentzel, Vasily Ponomarev, Cruz Lucius
When you review the trade tree from the Jake Guentzel deal, these are the list of players and picks they ended up with. They made different moves after the Guentzel trade that created a long list of prospects, players, and picks. Perhaps the diamond in the rough out of this move so far is Tommy Novak. He's not a special player, but he's dependable and can play at different positions for them.
Villie Koivunen is someone the Penguins are trying to force into a breakout year, but he continues to disappoint.
He was the centerpiece of the Guentzel deal, and he has yet to prove himself as a quality NHL forward. Perhaps Koivunen is destined to be a fringe NHL player who is out of the league sooner than one would like to admit. He has become one of the toughest failures by Dubas since this move.
Another potential bright spot could be Harrison Brunicke. He was the second round pick sent over to Pittsburgh by Carolina in that deal. Although he is still developing in the minors, he continues to be a potential bright spot for the Penguins in the future. Maybe he won't live up to the billing, but the hope is that Brunicke could become a solid defenseman for Pittsburgh in the next year or two.
Markus Ruck provides a nice story as different trades expanding the Guentzel trade tree allowed the Penguins to have an extra second-round pick in 2026 to pair him with his twin. Ruck still has a long way to go before anyone can get excited about him. Surprisingly the tree from this deal is not over as the Penguins still have a 4th round pick expanding from this deal that they will use in 2027.
